Weekly Updates

Let us know what you think about the site - what we're doing right or wrong, what you'd like to see, and any questions you might have. We'll toss some of our own thoughts and opinions in as well, including notes on the Weekly Updates at the main site.
Forum rules
* Nothing involving children on the receiving end of spankings!
* Be nice.
* Please keep to the forum subject. If you have an idea for a new forum, please send a PM to web-ed.
Post Reply
daneldorado

Re: Weekly Updates

Post by daneldorado »

Hiya Web-ed... those are some nice, tasty Updates this week.

The first one, a Homer Provence toon showing a girl getting a birthday spanking from her man, shows us the spankee with a big, bright smile. As you have noted in the past, most Homer spank toons do show the spankee smiling, and here you can see she is really enjoying it!

In my view, this kind of toon brings us the best of both worlds. Yes, I like to look at, and to draw, punitive spankings. But my pleasure is doubled when I can see that the girl on the receiving end is enjoying herself as much as her spanker, if that's possible. :D

In my younger years, I actually did meet girls who enjoyed this sort of treatment. Once, I spanked a girl for about 30 minutes, then said "okay, your punishment is over," just to stay in character. And you know what? She would not let me leave. She wanted MORE! So yes, I did stay with her for another 10 minutes or so, and warmed her bottom thoroughly. She was still smiling, at the end.

The Kirk Stiles toon is one I had seen before, but this scan is much better. Thanks!

There has been some discussion on this thread about the man and what he is doing with his right hand, shoring up his left (spanking) arm. I think the reason Stiles did that is to show us that the spanking has not yet begun. You know, in most cases when you see a one-panel spanking toon, the man's hand is up in the air and we get the idea that the spanking is already in progress. But in this toon, Stiles lets us see that it is still coming. The caption adds to that understanding.

The Batman/Catwoman spanking toon is the best Update this week. Dunno who drew this, but this dude is a real artist. The over-the-knee pose is letter perfect, and CW's fanny is nice and high. We can see Batman's handprints on her behind already, and the spanking is still ongoing! Everything about this drawing is wonderful. Seeing the Bat-signal in the sky is an added treat.

Cheers,
Dan
web-ed
Site Admin
Posts: 3341
Joined: Sun Nov 08, 2009 5:30 pm
Location: Chicago, Illinois USA
Contact:

Re: Weekly Updates for 07/06/2012

Post by web-ed »

hugob00m wrote: You've commented before, and again this time about Kirk Stiles and the ambiguous underwear he has his women wearing. I'm thinking he had "cami-knickers" in mind, but it's hard to tell for sure. And, even though the lady's about-to-be-spanked backside is the center of attention, I sort of wonder about the man's right arm? Does he have to support his spanking arm (in this case the left) while he has it raised up high? Is he rolling up his sleeve? (That seems like the most likely possibility, but then, that raises the question, If he's rolling up his sleeve, why doesn't he take his jacket off first?) One other little thing I'll nitpick is her position. I suppose that for paddling or caning it might be preferable to have the lady kneeling on the seat of a chair bent over the back, but for a hand-spanking, nothing is better than the good-ol' OTK position!
I think the spanker is rolling up his sleeve, but as you point out, Stiles should have drawn him with his jacket removed. Stiles never fixes little mistakes like this, which I always attributed to lack of time, although fixing an ink-wash wouldn't have been easy. On the position, while OTK is the King of Positions among spankos, Stiles varied his positions quite a bit more than the other members of the "Big Five" (Ward sometimes uses a bending-over position also). I think both men in these cases were aiming for compositional variety rather than spanking excellence. I agree with you that the position he drew here would have worked better with the paddle or cane, which is true of the bending-over positions generally.

Another factor may have been the early history of the spanking cartoon, a subject upon which I'm sure to write an essay one of these days. In going over old humor material before the first true (OTK) spanking cartoon, I find that the gag revolves around a woman bending over and a man taking advantage of the target being proffered, with hand, paddle, umbrella, or dentures! Perhaps OTK was considered too suggestive of a blatantly erotic experience in these early days, and Stiles must have been familiar with these older cartoons.
overbarrel49 wrote:i like the Homer birthday spanking. it appears that a good time is being had by all :D . do you have any idea what the little thing that looks like a camera drawn with white lines is that appears in the bottom right corner of the first version you have posted but not in the other 2?
The camera is an indication that we're looking at some original art that was photographed for auction. I've forgotten now which auction house it was, although it may have been Heritage or Worthpoint. Since the other two versions were taken by me from actual Humorama digests, the camera-symbol of course was lacking.
Butch wrote:The Teen Titan paddling of Duela Dent is good only the spankee facial expression should have been more pain than smile! Love the way Ravager is swinging that paddle! and a like how Miss Dent bottom is trusts up high on the spanking horse! what a big rump she have :lol: Ravager is also shapely to bad her bottom isn`t spanked maybe by Cyborg :twisted: anyway nice drawing!
With Duela's facial expression, I should have explained that Raven and Ravager have given her a dose of her own laughing formula - I forget what it's called exactly - and that's why she can't help smiling. So we may rest assured that while Duela may be smiling on the outside, she's crying out "Yee-Ouch!" on the inside! Maybe I'll add a note to the page.
daneldorado wrote:There has been some discussion on this thread about the man and what he is doing with his right hand, shoring up his left (spanking) arm. I think the reason Stiles did that is to show us that the spanking has not yet begun. You know, in most cases when you see a one-panel spanking toon, the man's hand is up in the air and we get the idea that the spanking is already in progress. But in this toon, Stiles lets us see that it is still coming. The caption adds to that understanding.
Dan makes another point I had forgotten to bring up myself: Stiles alone among the "Big Five" sometimes composes his cartoons to depict the time before the spanking has begun, especially when he's using a bending-over position. We'll see one shortly in which the boss is beckoning the secretary to turn over his knee, and another in which the boss orders the secretary to fetch the paddle! I'll touch upon this point again in my "Big Five" essay, currently being written.

I'm glad that everyone liked these updates. :)
-- Web-Ed
web-ed
Site Admin
Posts: 3341
Joined: Sun Nov 08, 2009 5:30 pm
Location: Chicago, Illinois USA
Contact:

Weekly Updates for 07/13/2012

Post by web-ed »

For links to the updates please visit the Home Page by clicking on "Chicago Spanking Review" at the top of this or any other forum page.

A couple of minor notes: (1) I've removed the "Next Week" blurb from the Home Page because I don't think it was too useful, and it was one more chore for me every week when I update the page. Most people will not even notice its absence. (2) Over the past few weeks I've been quietly renovating the Doc Cylon Gallery page, increasing the size of its thumbnails and adding descriptions to the early ones. This is now complete in case you want to take a look.

Now for the updates:
  • Doctor Cylon update, as he adds even more versions to "Penelope's Paddlings". I didn't mark them, but they're the last two at the bottom of the page.
  • Humorama update: New scan of Kirk Stiles' "Secretary Pilloried and Paddled for Lateness".
  • Humorama Series #97 - A spanking is given to help the spankee be good - an unusual (for Humorama) maintenance spanking.
Super-Spanking Summer II continues with
  • Batman spanks Batgirl by Nik Zula. A nice blend of sexiness and humor that many of you have probably seen before from this well-known modern spanking cartoonist, but certainly worth revisiting.
  • Cheetah spanks Wonder Woman. This is a very stylish version of a scene we've probably seen dozens of times (WW over someone's knee) by Frank Fly. We don't have any other of his spanking art, alas.
-- Web-Ed
hugob00m
Posts: 7209
Joined: Thu Nov 04, 2010 9:57 pm

Re: Weekly Updates

Post by hugob00m »

Great updates as usual!
web-ed wrote:Humorama update: New scan of Kirk Stiles' "Secretary Pilloried and Paddled for Lateness".
This is my favorite this week, even though I usually don't like "bondage", even in humorous drawings. The idea of a pillory in an office is so ludricous that it makes me laugh, and the girl's question is too! Is she really that naive... or is she being sarcastic about him wanting to brush her hair? (The look on her face suggests that she might really be that naive!)
User avatar
overbarrel49
Posts: 3149
Joined: Sat Feb 05, 2011 7:51 am

Re: Weekly Updates

Post by overbarrel49 »

hi web-ed,

Doc Cylon seems to have 2 special skills if you ask me. one, for making a bottom look like it's been freshly and thoroughly spanked and two, having a great eye for which bottoms are the nicest bottoms to do that to. good eye Doc :D . i don't remember seeing the Stiles pillory spanking before. it certainly seems unusual for a humorama spanking but what the hell. everyone is smiling and the gag's not too bad. the maintenance spanking is also unusual but i have to agree with your comments about it. we have a nice looking spankee, otk and accepting her spanking so what's not to like :D . i got a kick out of the batman spanks batgirl drawing :lol: . i think the expression on batgirl's face is perfect for the situation but you don't often see the spanker look that surprised :lol: . i have to agree with you about the expressions of the women in the wonder woman spanking. something is going on there...................hmmmmmmmmmmmmm. good updates this week. thanks, phil
daneldorado

Re: Weekly Updates

Post by daneldorado »

Hiya Web-ed:

This week I very much enjoyed seeing and downloading the Kirk Stiles toons about the pilloried secretary, and I really had to laugh at the caption. Oh Lord, how can that poor secretary NOT know why her boss is now brandishing his hairbrush? I wonder, too, if he is going to raise her skirt for the spanking (as is usual in spank toons), or allow it to stay down, considering the position she is in. Don't mind me, that's just my feverish brain thinking out loud.

And here again, as we saw last week in another Kirk toon, the boss is steadying his spanking hand with his other hand. Anticipatory much? :lol:

You say in your commentary: "We could find no record of corporal punishment being used in conjunction with the pillory..." Did you ever see the 1968 soft-porn flick, "Starlet?" In that one, a dude named David Friedman gets to whip the bare bottom of an actress called Shari Mann while she is confined in a pillory.

The "maintenance spanking" toon is one I had never seen before, so naturally I am glad to have it. We've seen a few of these in the past, for example that toon where the spanker is telling his lady that he's spanking her because he's mad at her for not giving him a good reason to spank her...! Ooh boy, can I relate. As a lifelong spanko, I can well remember days of my youth when I would spank my lady for no particular reason, except that I felt like doing it and I knew she wouldn't mind. Only once, out of maybe a dozen such examples, did I reckon incorrectly, and she yelled at me to stop. Of course I stopped immediately. Obviously that was our last date.

In your comments, you complained that: "Stiles does bulge the thighs out somewhat, but except for that this is an excellent cartoon...." Heck, Web-ed, I kinda LIKE generous thighs on a beautiful woman. We've seen so many pics -- both toons and photos -- in which the girl spankee has legs that look like toothpicks. Yecch.

And you are quite right, about the Batman/Batgirl toon. It IS superior to the same artist's previous opus, "Batman spanks Catwoman." I enjoy seeing Nik Zula's work, for he is obviously "one of us," a dedicated spanko. But for some reason that escapes me, Zula usually gives his spankees "pointed" buttcheeks. I dunno if "pointed" is the right word, but they do seem to taper to an acute angle. However, he doesn't do that with his Batgirl cartoon here. You say that hers is "a nice, round, spankable bottom," and you are correct.

Great stuff, Nick. Keep 'em coming.

Cheers,
Dan
butch46163@yahoo.com
Posts: 1439
Joined: Fri May 13, 2011 7:22 pm

Re: Weekly Updates

Post by butch46163@yahoo.com »

HI WEB-ED CSR!! It been a long time since I saw The Wacky Races on tv but I love the drawings of Penelope Pitstop getting her comeuppance! Don`t think The Ant Hill Mob could save her shaply large bottom from the wicket hands of Doctor Cylon and his spanking tools :lol: How bad a girl was she to get sent to her room maybe Doctor Cylon should have turned her over his knees for a long hairbrush spanking ! I bet Muttly the dog would be snickering at that :lol: Great drawings! Love the shock on Batman`s face as he discover that Batgirl is really Barbara Gordon :lol: It looks as though he afraid to continue spanking her. Wonder how he knew that was Barbara`s bottom ;) Like how Niki Zula Batgirl`s bottom is very curvy and round as it is sticking up high on Batman one knee. I think she should have been down over his lap :D Nice drawing 8-) Wonder Woman really have a plump tush and it`s no wonder :D Cheetah want to spank it ;) as much as I wanted to see WW get a real punishment spanking this is ok :D Love how she is position over Cheetah`s big powerful thighs this girl is very well built :D and how her lower bottom cheeks is a nice shape of red! Also can see Wonder Woman is enjoying the spanking maybe because she is glad someone finally took her in hand :lol: any way this is a very good spanking drawing :twisted: The boss in the Kirk Stile`s Secretary spanked for being late should have made her took off her high heels before putting that brush across her bottom unless he don`t mind getting kick in the you know where :lol: What makes this drawing so funny is the humor Do she think this guy is going to brush her hair :lol: Like how Stile has the secretary restrained in a pilloried . Only wish he made the boss hike up her long dress and spanked her pantied bottom :D really like a drawing that let you imagine what is going to happen :lol: 8-) The other Stiles drawing is also great love it because it is over the knees and on the panty :lol: Great position of the wife over her husband`s knees with panty bottom up high :lol: also like that the husband is spanking with the right hand ! maybe this spanking will keep her in line even though she haven`t done anything bad yet :lol: :twisted:
Tanner
Posts: 222
Joined: Sat Jan 23, 2010 10:07 am

Re: Weekly Updates

Post by Tanner »

Haven't been around much the past 2-3 weeks what with moving, power loss due to the storm that swept the mid-Atlantic states, a new computer set-up, etc. But you just keep the good stuff coming.
Never seem to run out of Humorama stuff. Those were the days when spankings could be seen in a mag at the local newstand.
And Doc Cylon always great. Loved his work on Penelope Pitstop and Wonder Woman. Now if he'd only give Xena the same redbottom, paddle-burn treatment. The mighty Warrior Princess standing, pain lines pouring from her red bottom, saying that she'll walk rather than ride her horse today.
Btw, there's a new Superman/Wonder Woman spanking over at Chross' blog page.
web-ed
Site Admin
Posts: 3341
Joined: Sun Nov 08, 2009 5:30 pm
Location: Chicago, Illinois USA
Contact:

Re: Weekly Updates for 07/13/2012

Post by web-ed »

daneldorado wrote: This week I very much enjoyed seeing and downloading the Kirk Stiles toons about the pilloried secretary, and I really had to laugh at the caption. Oh Lord, how can that poor secretary NOT know why her boss is now brandishing his hairbrush? I wonder, too, if he is going to raise her skirt for the spanking (as is usual in spank toons), or allow it to stay down, considering the position she is in. Don't mind me, that's just my feverish brain thinking out loud.

You say in your commentary: "We could find no record of corporal punishment being used in conjunction with the pillory..." Did you ever see the 1968 soft-porn flick, "Starlet?" In that one, a dude named David Friedman gets to whip the bare bottom of an actress called Shari Mann while she is confined in a pillory.

In your comments, you complained that: "Stiles does bulge the thighs out somewhat, but except for that this is an excellent cartoon...." Heck, Web-ed, I kinda LIKE generous thighs on a beautiful woman. We've seen so many pics -- both toons and photos -- in which the girl spankee has legs that look like toothpicks. Yecch.

And you are quite right, about the Batman/Batgirl toon. It IS superior to the same artist's previous opus, "Batman spanks Catwoman." I enjoy seeing Nik Zula's work, for he is obviously "one of us," a dedicated spanko. But for some reason that escapes me, Zula usually gives his spankees "pointed" buttcheeks. I dunno if "pointed" is the right word, but they do seem to taper to an acute angle. However, he doesn't do that with his Batgirl cartoon here. You say that hers is "a nice, round, spankable bottom," and you are correct.

Great stuff, Nick. Keep 'em coming.
Thanks, Dan! You know, I always wondered whether the boss was going to pull the secretary's dress up in that "pillory spanking" too - I guess great minds think (or at least wonder) alike. My guess was that the nearly-vertical position wouldn't allow her dress to be raised. I missed the pillory-whipping in Starlet? - in fact, I missed Starlet? entirely. Thanks for giving CSR readers something to look into should they be so inclined. Historically, I don't believe whipping accompanied he pillory, although I seem to remember something close to a spanking threat in The Scarlet Letter. I'll have to look it up for the "Spanking in Prose" subforum.

On the "bulging thighs" question: I agree with you about having shapely, full thighs - I like 'em too, mainly because genetically they're often matched with a shapely, full rear end! :) Stiles' occasional problem is that he bulges the thighs out backwards, behind the behind, which is anatomically incorrect:
Image
Above, you can see the "bulging thighs"; below, they're not as bad, but Stiles is pushing his luck a little.
Image

On Nik Zula's cartoon: I may have coined "bulging thighs" but you're right about the "pointed butt" that Zula sometimes uses. Batgirl's butt in this cartoon didn't have that flaw, and was "measurably" better! Butch commented on this "point" also. :)
tanner wrote:Haven't been around much the past 2-3 weeks what with moving, power loss due to the storm that swept the mid-Atlantic states, a new computer set-up, etc. But you just keep the good stuff coming.
Never seem to run out of Humorama stuff. Those were the days when spankings could be seen in a mag at the local newstand.
And Doc Cylon always great. Loved his work on Penelope Pitstop and Wonder Woman. Now if he'd only give Xena the same redbottom, paddle-burn treatment. The mighty Warrior Princess standing, pain lines pouring from her red bottom, saying that she'll walk rather than ride her horse today.
Btw, there's a new Superman/Wonder Woman spanking over at Chross' blog page.
Hope your A/C and computer are both doing o.k. by now, Tanner! I'm doing my best to keep the good stuff, including the Humorama material, coming - I'm not sure how long we'll carry on Super-Spanking Summer II, but it will certainly be well into September, while with Humorama, we're at #97 in the series (with 148 Humorama spankers now posted here!), and I have enough remaining cartoons to last most of the rest of this year. I also have two or three non-Humorama spanking cartoons from other men's magazines in the 50's, and we'll be seeing those sometime next year.

I had already nabbed that Superman/Wonder Woman spanking over at Chross' blog and will probably incorporate it into a WW special week here, but thanks for the heads-up anyway.

I don't have too much more from Doctor Cylon - just some updates to existing pages - but he may always send me some more stuff. Let's hope he does.
-- Web-Ed
web-ed
Site Admin
Posts: 3341
Joined: Sun Nov 08, 2009 5:30 pm
Location: Chicago, Illinois USA
Contact:

Weekly Updates for 07/20/2012

Post by web-ed »

For links to the updates please visit the Home Page by clicking on "Chicago Spanking Review" at the top of this or any other forum page.
  • Doctor Cylon update - he adds two more versions to "Ariel Gets Paddled".
  • Humorama update: New scan of Kirk Stiles' "Secretary Spanked by Female Boss".
  • Humorama Series #98 - High-Handed Secretary Spanking. We don't think this one has ever been seen on the 'net before.
Super-Spanking Summer II continues with
  • A Generic Superhero Spanking Scene by Tim. Tim made up these super-hereoes, so you won't recognize them, but you will recognize the OTK action!
  • Robin spanks Batgirl by David Marshall. An extended spanking scene in which Robin has finally had enough!
-- Web-Ed
User avatar
overbarrel49
Posts: 3149
Joined: Sat Feb 05, 2011 7:51 am

Re: Weekly Updates

Post by overbarrel49 »

hi web-ed,

nice rosy cheeks by Doc Cylon this week as usual. the second scan of the Kirk Stiles secretary spanked by female boss is vastly superior as you mentioned. i like the bending over position and the idea that she won't be doing any sitting around :lol: . i also like the inquisitive nature of the co workers in the background :lol: . the high handed drawing seems less well done to me. i like the bending over position less well and also the proportions of the spankee but it's still a nice idea and a nice drawing :D . interesting superhero spanking drawing by Tim. like you, i'll be interested in watching future drawings by him. i like the Robin spanks Batgirl. now that's the kind of comics i like to see :D . more good updates. thanks, phil
hugob00m
Posts: 7209
Joined: Thu Nov 04, 2010 9:57 pm

Re: Weekly Updates for 07/20/2012

Post by hugob00m »

web-ed wrote:Robin spanks Batgirl by David Marshall. An extended spanking scene in which Robin has finally had enough!
Oh yes! This is my favorite part of your update this week!
web-ed wrote:Let's savor two pages of "Batgirl's Bad Day", taking up the story where Robin has had enough and decides it's time to take her OTK. Marshall appears to have done this using traditional comic-art techniques - ink on paper (we don't know if he pencilled it first, but he probably did). Note the cameo appearance of Jughead Jones from Archie in the first panel.
Indeed! Let's savor those pages! Sometime I'd like to know the rest of the story of "Batgirl's Bad Day" and maybe if there was any specific reason for Robin to decide that Batgirl needed to be spanked right then and there. Was there a "last straw", that pushed Robin past the limits of his patience? Was it just the cumulative effect of dealing with her usual haughtiness? Or, maybe, considering her remark about his hard-on poking her belly... it was just that he was so sexually frustrated by her flirtiness, and her provocative costume, that he had to do something!
The addition of Jughead was funny.
web-ed wrote:Batgirl was always somewhat impudent in the comics, and as played by Yvonne Craig on TV we really wanted to see her get taken down a peg because of the "haughty, I-deserve-to-be-spanked attitude"
Didn't it seem like every character that Yvonne Craig ever played should've been spanked?
butch46163@yahoo.com
Posts: 1439
Joined: Fri May 13, 2011 7:22 pm

Re: Weekly Updates

Post by butch46163@yahoo.com »

HI WEB-ED CSR!! Like the drawing of Ariel being spanked with a paddle by Doctor Cylon :twisted: Only problem is he should have taken her on land and spanked her :lol: Don`t think using a paddle underwater has much force ! Nice bottom she have would love to see her spanked as a Mermaid otk :twisted: Really love Kirk Stile`s High handed secretary spanking ! As much as I love otk position seeing this well built woman bent over a desk with her dress raise up getting spanked is great :D Love her reaction and the humor. Also love how the boss`s hand is cock way back to deliever the spanking :lol: Great drawing :!: :!: The other Stile`s drawing is also nice wonder if the acting boss is spanked by her boss :?: :lol: Good bent over position nice pantyclad bottom and you are right she should use a pointer or ruler on the secretary`s bottom :) The spanking of Batgirl by Robin is the best!! Love the over the knees position plus her struggling and facial expressing Robin is laying it on thick to her bottom :lol: Also love how her bottom flating when spanked add on kicking and pain lines making this drawing the best 8-) Love to see her spanked in her Batgirl suit! Robin might be young but he a good spanker juding by this drawing The Bat taught him well :lol: Generic Super hore drawing is nice ! nice plump bottom on the female spankee good otk postion :D Only the other girl on the left looks real young and flat :lol: Nice drawing!!!
daneldorado

Re: Weekly Updates

Post by daneldorado »

Hiya Web-ed:

Oh Dear God, this week's new updates contain two of the most orgasmically delightful spanking images ever to come down the pike. Thank you so much!

Of course the "Ariel" stuff doesn't excite me, as it is just Doc Cylon tinkering with an already extant pic. The later pencil pic by someone named "Tim" is nice, but I think Tim should continue to fine-tune his artistic skills. Maybe move into inking and coloring, and adding some tone and shading to his work.

But things get a little better with your new scan of the F/F toon you call "Secretary Spanked by Female Boss". The new detailing is very good, and it is indeed a nice pic, enhanced by our view of the two guys in the background looking on. But, as good a cartoon as this is, I won't be downloading it, because I generally save my disk space for M/F pics.

Much better is your new scan of the "high-handed" spanking. This is a Kirk Stiles toon that, somehow, I had missed seeing before. Because of the desk, the chair, the file cabinet, and the way the parties are dressed, I assume this is an office encounter. The well-dressed guy we assume is the boss, and the girl is his secretary. In spite of the fact that this is not an OTK toon, it is enchanting. I love the positioning and I like that the girl is holding up her own skirt to facilitate her spanking. That's a clue that there may be a consensual component to this spanking, and I like that...a LOT!

Also, this girl has something you and I have discussed before, namely, the generous thighs that Kirk Stiles always gives his spankees. Since I am Hispanic, I like my women with a lot of meat on 'em; so yeah, I really like big thighs on a girl, assuming they are shapely. And of course Stiles always sees to it that they ARE. The petite feet are another feature I like about Stiles' work. They are always small, but not distractingly so.

But, like a true artist, YOU, web-ed, have saved the best for last. Your final post for this week's super-special updates is ridiculously good... it's GREAAAAAAT!!

Oh my God, what a delightful surprise you have given us here! Robin, the Boy Wonder, is now actually giving Batgirl a good, sound over-the-knee spanking... and it is no small, friendly paddy-whacking between partners. No, Robin is giving it to her with both barrels. What a delightful idea!

I have tried to do research on the Batman-Robin-Batgirl characters, but nothing on Google or Wikipedia tells me their respective ages. Of course Batman is the oldest of the three, his story having debuted in 1939, and Robin the Boy Wonder came along (as a teenager) in 1940. But we never know their respective ages. Batgirl apparently did not arrive on the scene until 1967; but in comic book depictions as well as on TV and movie screens, she seems to be about Robin's age.

What I especially like about the Robin/Batgirl spanking is its length -- it is depicted in, I think, about eight (8!) panels -- plus the ferocity with which Batgirl struggles (in vain) to escape her ordeal. She is strong, of course; but here, we can see that Robin is stronger still. He successfully holds down the desperately struggling female and delivers an excruciatingly painful punishment to her bouncing bottom until she is, finally, thoroughly chastised and vanquished.

All along, I was thinking: Hey, this Robin looks younger than the woman across his lap. She seems to be as tall as he, as far as we can tell from the positions, and so I fantasized that Robin was actually spanking a (slightly) older woman. In those moments when I was thinking that, in my mind I was thinking about my own "Tommy and Miss Johnson" cartoons. This cartoon, apparently by someone named David Marshall, had me thinking Batgirl was the older of the two characters... especially when we "hear" her wondering "how does a boy his age have such a strong grip?"

And it was a nice touch, when we also "hear" Batgirl thinking that Robin's boner had poked her in the stomach. That line, also, had me thinking she was the elder of the two.

Well, after all these years, finally Robin the Boy Wonder and I have something in common. After this event, we both had to change our undies.

Cheers,
Dan
web-ed
Site Admin
Posts: 3341
Joined: Sun Nov 08, 2009 5:30 pm
Location: Chicago, Illinois USA
Contact:

Re: Weekly Updates for 07/20/2012

Post by web-ed »

daneldorado wrote:Oh Dear God, this week's new updates contain two of the most orgasmically delightful spanking images ever to come down the pike. Thank you so much!
You're most welcome, Dan! Nothing I like better than sharing my spanking discoveries (and essays) with my friends. :)

I don't think I need to say much more about the Kirk Stiles "High-handed Secretary Spanking", which was well-received. I have one more of Stiles that probably no one has seen before, and then a couple after that which may or may not be familiar. Stiles is going to come in at #2 after only Bill Ward as to the number of "spankers" done for Humorama, and it's just barely possible that there is still another Stiles cartoon we've yet to discover. Some months back, I predicted there still might be unknown "spankers" by Ward and Morrice, and sure enough, I've since discovered one more by each of these men which we'll be seeing later. I think we've exhausted the supply from Homer and DeCarlo, however, and I would be very surprised to find something previously unknown from either man at this point.

Speaking of Humorama, next week we'll have Part 1 of my comparative essay on the spanking art of these men (plus Bill Wenzel of course).

Everyone loved the Robin/Batgirl scene by David Marshall. Would you believe I'd been sitting on that one for over a year? It just shows how backed up things can get - once I couldn't get to it during Super-Spanking Summer #1, it had to wait for the changing of the seasons! I'm going to try hard to get through all my remaining super-stuff this summer, although it's going to be tough.
hugob00m wrote:Sometime I'd like to know the rest of the story of "Batgirl's Bad Day" and maybe if there was any specific reason for Robin to decide that Batgirl needed to be spanked right then and there.
As far as I know, Marshall never finished the story. It's possible he might still do so - as you know, the artist's life isn't an easy one, and sometimes favorite projects have to sit on the back burner while the rent is being paid with other things. One of the great things about it is that it is a whole story, which allowed for an extended spanking scene over a number of separate panels.
daneldorado wrote: I have tried to do research on the Batman-Robin-Batgirl characters, but nothing on Google or Wikipedia tells me their respective ages. Of course Batman is the oldest of the three, his story having debuted in 1939, and Robin the Boy Wonder came along (as a teenager) in 1940. But we never know their respective ages. Batgirl apparently did not arrive on the scene until 1967; but in comic book depictions as well as on TV and movie screens, she seems to be about Robin's age.
So you want to know more about the relative ages of the Dynamic Duo (plus 1), but couldn't find this information elsewhere? Because all these characters have been "retconned" it's confusing trying to tell one version from another in sources like Wikipedia (which I wouldn't rely on for anything important anyway). Curious to know if Robin might be spanking an older woman, much like Tommy and Miss Johnson? Well, you've come to the right place :D !
The relationship between Batman, Batgirl, and Robin could get strange at times.  From Detective Comics #369 (Nov. 1967).  Art by Gil Kane and Sid Greene.
The relationship between Batman, Batgirl, and Robin could get strange at times. From Detective Comics #369 (Nov. 1967). Art by Gil Kane and Sid Greene.
robin_tug_of_war_detective_no_369.jpg (186.56 KiB) Viewed 4157 times
It was something of a tradition in super-hero comics, or at least a convenience, that character ages were left unspecified in the stories themselves. Among other things, writers could avoid tripping over continuity problems that way. In some cases, there was a behind-the-scenes understanding: the pre-Byrne Superman so many of us grew up with from the 50's through the 70's, for instance, was 29, although this was never stated specifically in any comic. In other cases, we can draw reasonable inferences from known information - at least if we have lots of back issues - and that's what we'll do here.

To begin with, Batman had already begun his career when he took Robin under his wing (and of course he would have had to be older anyway to have been appointed Robin's legal guardian). Since Batman went through college and then spent some time getting additional training before starting out, this would seem to make him at least 25. Supposing Robin to have been about 15 when he joined up with Batman, that gives us an age difference of about 10 years between the two.

Some time passed before Batgirl hit the scene, and although Robin was still in high school he may have been more like 17 or 18. Batgirl had already graduated college, and since she's a full-fledged librarian in her early stories, she would have either a post-graduate degree or some work experience, making her about 25 or 26. This is confirmed by her later, somewhat improbable career as a Congresswoman (during the comics of the '70's) which requires that she be at least 25.

That means Robin did indeed get to enjoy the thrill of spanking a Batgirl who was 7 or even 8 years older than he was :D ! And Marshall was certainly aware of this, as evidenced by Batgirl's "a boy his age" remark. It also means we should consider commissioning some Robin/Batgirl scenes when we can - it would be great fun to highlight her embarrassment at being spanked by a younger man!
-- Web-Ed
daneldorado

Re: Weekly Updates

Post by daneldorado »

.
Hiya Web-ed:

As usual, you are right. Robin and Batgirl have been personified as different people, in different versions of the Batman story. Especially is this true of Batgirl. As you said, she has been a librarian, a Congresswoman, and only recently seen as Barbara Gordon, daughter of the Gotham police commissioner. Her age bounces around, too, from version to version.

I found one pic that indicates she and Robin are approximately the same age:

Image

I have no idea what year this picture was drawn, nor in which version of the Batman saga it appears. But as you say, there have been several.

Naturally, it doesn't matter much what her age is, as long as she is pretty and as long as she gets spanked. Let's hope we eventually get to see another Batgirl spanking scene that's as vigorous as the one you posted in this week's updates.

Cheers,
Dan
web-ed
Site Admin
Posts: 3341
Joined: Sun Nov 08, 2009 5:30 pm
Location: Chicago, Illinois USA
Contact:

Batgirl 1 and Batgirl 2

Post by web-ed »

Dan - In the panels you've found, it's certainly true that Batgirl and Robin are about the same age - but it's a different Batgirl! She's Batgirl #1 (Betsy Kane), and she only made about a half-dozen appearances back in the early 60's. I can't positively identify the issue this kiss came from, but it was probably an issue of Batman rather than one of the other Bat-Family titles, and the pencils appear to be Sheldon Moldoff's (uncredited at that time and working under Bob Kane's signature).

The Batgirl we enjoyed seeing spanked in this week's updates was definitely Batgirl #2, Barbara Gordon. Some further discussion of these characters may be found in Two Batgirls for the (Andy) Price of One although I pulled the art from the page a couple of years ago.
-- Web-Ed
Tanner
Posts: 222
Joined: Sat Jan 23, 2010 10:07 am

Re: Weekly Updates

Post by Tanner »

I loved this week's, all of them. Nice to see that Robin is as accomplished as a spanker as his mentor. And I agree there is something appealing about women getting spanked by men younger than they are, the role reversal factor I suppose -ie. Miss Johnson and her pupil.
The one by Tim . The girl with pain lines coming out of the seat of her tight shorts is a topnotch "after" artwork.
Really liked the dialogue with the F/F spanking, always nice to see a reference to sitting difficulties that a spankee may face.
butch46163@yahoo.com
Posts: 1439
Joined: Fri May 13, 2011 7:22 pm

Re: Weekly Updates

Post by butch46163@yahoo.com »

HI WEB-ED CSR!! Wasn`t there a comic back in the 60 where Batman was going to marry Batgirl? Meaning she has to be older than robin! :) Can`t say much about the new Batgirl who was a young girl that came after Robin left to become Nightwings! If anyone who I thought would give Batgirl a spanking it has to be the Joker! :lol:
hugob00m
Posts: 7209
Joined: Thu Nov 04, 2010 9:57 pm

Re: Weekly Updates

Post by hugob00m »

I found your essay on the Big Five plus One to be both interesting and informative. Also, I'm honored that you refer to the "hugob00m theory" several times. Since we have so little information about the inclinations of the artists, we have to look for clues in the art itself. Using the "hugob00m theory" together with the "overbarrel theory", we can, perhaps, get a bit of insight into the thoughts and feelings of the artists.

Regarding Bill Wenzel: As you and many others have observed, he seems to be too sloppy with his positioning to be really "into" spankings. On the other hand, I find his drawings to be quite erotic because of the affectionate way he draws the backsides of his women. The quote from his daughter that all of Wenzel's women "looked like Mom", is probably the best indication that he found the "zaftig" women to be the most attractive. More than most of the "Big Five plus One", I can look at his non-spanking cartoons and think of how nice it would be if a man would just turn the lady over his knee!

...And there's going to be a part two? Good! I'll be looking forward to it!
Post Reply