Chicago Spanking Review Forum

As always enjoyed the weekly wonders.
My favorite is the Intimate Confessions one. A woman who did what she did certainly deserved a spanking. Too bad the comics code didn't permit it to be shown the way it should have been shown-her dress up and maybe her panties down as well.
The Lara Croft was the usual great art we expect from Doc Cylon. Wasnt a great fan of those movies-but always in favor of any character played by Angelina Jolie getting a spanking. Like to see one from her 1994 movie Foxfire where she played the leader of a teenage girl gang. Her and her followers so needed their bottoms blistered.
Like the suggestion about a female doctor getting spanked. How about by a male nurse or orderly who she has shown disrespect to,treating them with disdain because she is a doctor and they are beneath her?

hi web-ed,

i thought i'd comment on the Halloween pic by wolfie 138 first. i really like it . first off those are some great looking ladies engaged in this graveyard spanking and i have to love the sheer sheets for their ghostly outfits . the leg locked otk position is good and i like the way the spanker is holding the spankee's hand. interesting that even with the sheets over their heads with only eye holes you can still plainly tell that the spanker is irritated and the spankee is in distress . nice curvy bottom and good coloring too . the lara croft pic is nice just the way it is but i like the doc cylon enhancements................especially the expression on the spankee's face. i really like the animation\............nice flattening of her bottom cheeks and good change of expression as the spanks land too . i do like the coloring of her bottom better in the original though. as for the ward spankings..............you mention in the doctor spanking that something seems a little off an you mention the chair below the knees. the same is true for the waitress spanking although to a lesser degree but i don't think that's what's bothering me about both these pics. in each case the top half of the spankee is in normal otk position but her bottom half seems to be completely off his lap and sticking out in front of him. the doctor spanking seems particularly bad about this to me but in either case i think the spankee's back would have to be broken for this position. i will say that the waitress is a good looking spankee though and i love the surprised look on her face. i like the "intimate confessions" spanking and the story leading up to it. don't you just love it when justice is served . good updates again. thanks much. phil

Hiya Web-ed:

Of all your new posts, I like the "Intimate Confessions - Far from Innocent" the best. That's probably because you have included the full comic strip, which shows the events leading up to the spanking. This "Connie" is truly Far from Innocent, going after her sister's new husband and trying to seduce him.

In a way, these "full-length" spanking strips are more satisfying than individual spank panels, anyway... much as your "Crime and Justice -- Diabolical Pipeline" strip from last week. Here, we are given the full story, not just the inevitable spanking... though of course, the spanking panels themselves are very satisfying.

Someone on this board -- maybe you, maybe one of our members? -- suggested that an OTK spanking given while seated on a couch is somewhat less than ideal, since there is less chance for the spankee to arch her back and position her fanny nice and high for its punishment. I never thought like that, especially since one of the most memorable spankings I ever gave involved a girl and a couch. The girl was a famous video star, and she had invited me to her apartment to "play." She knew I was married, so spanking was the only "playing" we did. But her bottom was lovely, and I'm pretty sure she did elevate it for me.

If you will believe me, I gave this gal's bare bottom a walloping of more than ONE THOUSAND swats! I know it was that many, because I -- unlike many of my spanko brethren -- have this accursed tendency of counting swats. I dunno why I do it, I just do it. Anyway, the spanking ended when the palm of my right hand split open, and Beverly got up and tenderly bandaged my hand after putting some antiseptic cream on it. The point is, spanking on the couch was perfectly fine.

As much as I enjoy coming here to the CSR, I think I will boycott next week's update, since you have indicated you intend to post only F/M pictures. Let me be clear: I do commend you for posting these items for the few members that actually enjoy F/M, and I admire your compassion for them. But since I disapprove of that particular configuration, I'll probably skip coming here next week, and let the misfits have their jollies. Since you have indicated that you don't like F/M any more than I do, I trust this will be the last of them.

Till then,

Cheers,
Dan

hey all, just wanted to say thanks for the feedback, glad you liked the pics

I'm pleased by the positive comments on this week's updates. Everyone seemed especially drawn to the Discord/Torment scene and Intimate Confessions #7. Dan mentioned the desirability of having the context of the spanking scene in material taken from the comics, and I will always give this if I have it.

overbarrel49 wrote:... as for the ward spankings..............you mention in the doctor spanking that something seems a little off an you mention the chair below the knees. the same is true for the waitress spanking although to a lesser degree but i don't think that's what's bothering me about both these pics. in each case the top half of the spankee is in normal otk position but her bottom half seems to be completely off his lap and sticking out in front of him. the doctor spanking seems particularly bad about this to me but in either case i think the spankee's back would have to be broken for this position. i will say that the waitress is a good looking spankee though and i love the surprised look on her face.

Maybe that's it, Phil - I knew something was wrong but couldn't quite place it.

daneldorado wrote:If you will believe me, I gave this gal's bare bottom a walloping of more than ONE THOUSAND swats! I know it was that many, because I -- unlike many of my spanko brethren -- have this accursed tendency of counting swats. I dunno why I do it, I just do it. Anyway, the spanking ended when the palm of my right hand split open, and Beverly got up and tenderly bandaged my hand after putting some antiseptic cream on it. The point is, spanking on the couch was perfectly fine.

I believe you Dan, but one thousand swats - wow! Beverly must have been pretty tough to be able to take so many swats and split your palm open (now you know why I like wooden paddles ). It's funny you mentioned counting the swats - I'd like to do that, what with my detail-obsessed mind, but I usually lose track when I try. I think something must be distracting me!


I will have two M/F items next week, by the way, another one from Bill Ward and one from Doctor Cylon, so those of you who, like Dan, wouldn't come by just for the Horror of the F/M cartoons will at least have something for consolation.

Dan also expressed the hope that this would be the last "Halloween Horror" week - I hope so, too! I'm only going to post F/M stuff if it's a) rare, and b) probably not available from any other source. Examples would be Golden Age comics involving a costumed superheroine, and old Humorama digests which are getting to be in pretty short supply. I doubt there are any more F/M scenes involving Golden Age superheroines, and my Humorama Search is winding down now, so we may hope there aren't any more undiscovered F/M cartoons there to disturb us.

Let me add my appreciation of the Halloween material too. The Wolf City Girls are always great to look at, being their naughty selves.
Really liked the Van Helsing one- a stake as a spanking implement ,that is a first. Maybe next year we can see a Buffy related spanking with a stake.
Only thing lacking for Halloween is Elvira getting spanked. Well, maybe one of these Octobers..

Tanner wrote:Only thing lacking for Halloween is Elvira getting spanked. Well, maybe one of these Octobers..

Elvira would be especially appropriate to this forum, with so many Midwesterners in it... Cassandra Peterson, who plays Elvira is originally a Kansas girl, and her sense of humor is very Midwestern.

i think there is an Elvira spanking out there somewhere. I also think jon (UASKETCHER) did indeed animate the Lara Croft spanking as i saw it in Underground Animations years ago. I love Nik Zula's works and i did not read who the artist was about the girl ghosts, but i did reconize them as Discord and her partner and great art as usual for them. As is the case on most of Ward's spankings there does always appear to be something amiss (angled wrong, floating spankees, etc), but i do enjoy his work. Thanks for the updates. On a private note you did say something about my favorite Homer spanking being posted in the summer and i have not seen it yet. (i can be impatient sometimes, although i really do enjoy almost all you post (not nessicarily the f/m), but i do enjoy all the rest. Thanks for sharing them
Jim

B00m and Tanner both mentioned Elvira - if there is an Elvira spanking out there, as Jim suggested, I haven't found it yet, but if I do, you can bet it's going up the very next Halloween season! I do have a delightful drawing of Vampirella spanking Buffy by Andy Price, and I was going to post it last year, but then Price asked me to remove his work from CSR so I never did.

As for the animated spanking of Lara Croft, it very likely was Jon who animated it, and Jim was correct about it being found on Underground Animations - I ran a program which downloaded all of UA's files, and a few days ago I did find this animation among them.

Jim also reminded me about my promise to get to my remaining Homer cartoons (I have two, including his favorite, plus two new scans of existing posts) by the end of the summer. Although the World Series is still going on, I must admit that summer is now over and I still haven't gotten to these yet . What really threw me off was that after Mike entrusted me with his Humorama collection, I wasn't expecting to commence a new Humorama search of my own - but I did, and one of the results was an unexpected find this year of six or seven more spankers by George Morrice. Because I had just "concluded" my Morrice sub-series, I decided to put the new Morrice stuff at the head of the line and I've been behind ever since.

So here's what we'll do: as soon as the current Bill Ward series concludes (on Veteran's Day, as it happens), I'll run whatever Homer cartoons I have in the files. I think I've got all the remaining ones, although one of them I had to extract from a cover scan and I still have a few more Humorama digests to go through. And Homer will get his day at last .

For links please visit the Home Page (click on "Chicago Spanking Review" at the top of this or any other Forum page to get there).

• Cigarette smoking leads to two smoking butts, from Doctor Cylon. Based on the work of Keith Garvey.
• #57 in the Humorama Series features a Bill Ward Forget-Me-Not spanking. This is the last of the photostats from what we believe to be Jeff Patton's collection, but we'll continue with Ward's work for another four episodes, concluding with #61 unless we find something more in the near future.

Then it's time for Halloween Horror, more F/M stuff (the horror being in the F/M orientation), which as readers may remember we also did last year but which we don't intend to turn into an annual event. It's just that we feel obligated to post these rare F/M items from Humorama, and we're going to rid our files of them all at once in the hope we won't discover any more. These will be placed in a segregated area of the Humor Gallery so they can be easily avoided, and will not be allowed to pollute the ongoing Humorama Series.

• Four from Bill Ward, which we're not even going to try to describe.
• A second from Kirk Stiles - nice setting on a beach with a pretty girl - he got everything right except the orientation. We believe Stiles only did two F/M.
• The only known F/M from Bill Wenzel - incomprehensible and a little shocking at the same time!

Next Week: Things get back to normal as the Humorama Series continues, the Golden Age Romance Comic Series concludes, and Doctor Cylon spanks on!

hi web-ed,

in the Keith Garvey drawing, you're right, Doc Cylon did know exactly what to do with it . i love the throbbing bottom in the animation too. the spankee obviously has something in mind here. looking at the fact her panties are still down, the heart in the smoke and the position of her red hand i'd say the spanker had best hurry back since it appears she's already started without him . just the kind of reaction i always hoped for from a good spanking . the ward spanker does look funny since the spankee is hovering over his lap instead of on it. as you noted the caption is pretty shaky too. ward must have been having a bad day when he did this one. i passed on checking out the rest of this week's update . we'll get back to normal next week. thanks, phil

Bit heavy on the F/M stuff mate!

willjohn wrote:Bit heavy on the F/M stuff mate!

You're right, Willjohn, but I felt it was better to get it over with all at once rather than dragging out the pain and discomfort week after week, like tearing off a bandage quickly. This way my F/M stock is exhausted (and I hope it won't be replenished).

I'd like to reiterate a few points:

• My personal interest is M/F, and that's where CSR's focus will remain. F/F strikes me as bland (with a few exceptions), F/M as backwards, and M/M as gay (which is fine if you're running a gay-interest website, but that's not CSR).
• Most of CSR's readers are primarily interested in M/F material, but a substantial proportion is interested in F/F and a small proportion in F/M.
• I feel my duty to the F/M folks is limited to bringing them rare items with genuine historical interest they probably could not get anyplace else. Examples would be the four (out of five) Mary Marvel scenes I posted last year, which only I knew about at the time because it was I who had discovered them (while looking for M/F, of course) or some of today's Humorama cartoons which, coming from my personal collection of the old digests, are probably not known to anyone else in the spanking scene and are of considerable historical interest because it is so remarkable they were published at that time (1950's) in that particular forum (working man's humor and pin-up magazine). I have discovered numerous F/M scenes in comics that I never have and never will post (see the Comics Spanking Data Base for examples) because they're simply not unusual enough (no superheroine involved, for instance).
• Although my duty to the F/M folks is limited, I feel it is a duty - if I don't post an item, they will probably never find it anywhere else (see the point above). Others are free to take the opposite point of view with their websites - that they have no obligations to the F/M crowd and simply won't post the stuff. It may cheer you to know I have the distinct impression that I'm not too popular with the F/M crowd, probably because of my repeated insistence that F/M is unnatural in comparison with M/F.
• The F/M stuff in the Humor Gallery is relegated to a small, labeled area at the bottom of the page so it can easily be avoided by those who don't want to see it.

I agree with most of the others that F/M is not my favorite. But for historical purposes, I understand that you need to document the F/M spankings you've found in old comics and Humorama publications. I appreciate that you've clearly labled them, so that no one will accidentally look at them if they don't want to. I did take a peek at them, and... WTF? There was that really strange Bill Wenzel cartoon with the woman holding up one hand like she was drawing back to spank her man, but why did she have an electric razor in her other hand? Did she plan to shave his butt too?

You said that your F/M readers never say anything good about the fact that you post F/M cartoons at all, but write in to complain because you say it's unnatural. I remember that the only time I ever included an F/M spanking in an O.T. Katie cartoon, no one in favor of F/M had anything so say.

HI WEB- ED!! Read a lot of F/m spankings in Eric Stanton and Gene Bilbrew comic don`t care for them much but some do carry a humiliation something I do enjoy seeing the man who is stronger brought down by the weaker sex and spanked like a naughty child or woman is humiliating to me But I rather see women on the receiving end any day!!Great job by Doctor Cylon Two Smoking Butts And judging how the lady is laying while smoking suggest she was turn on by the spanking she just got Bill Ward`s Forget me not is Forgettable poor position like her breast is balance on his knee nice buttock although flat maybe Ward wasn`t in the mood that day ! THANKS!!

Butch,
Stanton did mostly F/M, although I have two of his M/F spankings posted in the Picture Gallery. Bilbrew did a lot of F/F stuff, including a couple of strange sorority paddling scenes involving weird mechanical bondage devices that I also have posted there. I think Stanton must have been into humiliation as you mentioned, although I don't remember his F/M stuff very well since I basically ignored it. Bilbrew understood the importance of a good back arch in the bending over position, which I think contributes greatly to the spankee's humiliation, but unfortunately never employed his knowledge in any M/F paddling scenes that I know of.

b00m,
Interesting that you didn't get any raves for that one scene from the F/M crowd either. I don't know why, since in your case although your work is overwhelmingly M/F, you haven't referred to F/M as "less natural" dozens of times as I have. Maybe the F/M people are just more shy about coming "out" - I could understand that.

And thanks for everyone for sticking with CSR through last week's Halloween Horror. Things are back to normal now, the Humorama and Golden Age Comics searches are proceeding this week, and we'll have plenty of good M/F stuff in the coming weeks, including two special features and the last of Ward's M/F cartoons all on Nov. 11.

For links please visit the Home Page (click on "Chicago Spanking Review" at the top of this or any other Forum page to get there).

• She promises to be good - if she can have another spanking from Doctor Cylon!
• It's time for Secretary Spanking #25 from Bill Ward as Miss Howard is sent to retrieve some files. Why do you suppose they happen to be from the lowest drawer in the cabinet?
• Also from Ward is Spanking the Maid #4. Ward seemed very comfortable with maid-spanking, and we certainly have no objections, except that it seems a little like Falconry - a sport for the upper class that us working class guys who don't have maids can't participate in.
• Golden Age Romance Comic spanking returns with another Western scene in which a stubborn cowgirl gets the seat of her britches set afire by a firm-handed cowboy. The comic was called My Secret, but it's no secret what the best method is for taming a wild cowgirl! We think this is a Canadian reprint of an original Fox publication, and Fox was known for, well, having a lot of foxy ladies within its pages, so a Fox spanking is always something to look forward to.

Other news this week: I moved the link to latest news and updates so it's near the top of the Home Page - this is a "same page" link that just moves you down the same page, in this case right to the links to this week's updates. It saves a bit of scrolling time for CSR's regular visitors who on a given visit may not need anything on the Home Page other than the newest updates.

Humorama Search: Ten more digests yielded no new spanking cartoons - maybe there aren't any more than the 164 I have - but I did get better-quality scans of two cartoons I have in the files but haven't posted yet.

Silver Age Supergirl Spanking Search: one more issue of Lois Lane searched, leaving one to go. As expected, no new spanking discovered.

Golden Age Comics Search: 1548 more pages searched, with no new M/F spankings except the one from Plastic Man that was brought to my attention by Johnny. We'll get around to it with the next superhero series.

Artastic Forum: my efforts to save it continue to be in vain. I did prepare a tribute to Jon in the form of a memorial gallery of 25 of his X/F spanking drawings, and this will be up next week.

Other stuff for next week:

• a young lady wanders into Doctor Cylon's playroom - big mistake!
• Humorama Series #60 and #61, as I finally reach the end of my Bill Ward stock
• Some excerpts from the Josie and the Pussycats animated cartoon - no true spankings, but Alexandra gets a sore caboose - seven times! This was a YouTube clip that Robin brought to my attention, and which I subsequently re-edited.
• One of the stranger comic-book spankings that I have ever seen. I held this one back for years trying to identify it, with no success. It may well be Atlas from the 1950's. The spankee willingly bends over, then tells the spanker to "go harder" - wild!

Loved seeing another Cowboy/Romance spanking.And loved use of the phrase "warmed the seat of her britches"-real oldtime oldfashioned spanking phrase.
As I may have mentioned before, am a great lover of seeing women in tight pants getting spanked. Tight pants make the target easy to find. Best of all is if she is getting a paddle used on the seat of her tight pants, for more sting than a palm would. Have any of those lying around?

"She will be good if she gets a spanking!"

That's my kinda girl!

Thank you for this week's update. My favorite this time is the Bill Ward maid spanking. She has a delightfully round posterior and her tight uniform shows it off nicely! I also liked the Cowboy Romance one, and I'm glad that, as you usually do, you included a bit of the story that led up to the heroine being spanked.