Chicago Spanking Review Forum

hugob00m wrote:I like it that you decided to use some peripheral characters from your previous story as the central characters of this one, and now the main characters of the previous story are going to be witnesses. And I love it when a woman is old enough to have a grown daughter, but is still young enough to get spanked!

I can already tell I'm gonna enjoy this one!

hi Boom,

i knew from the beginning that i wanted this to be a story about a mom getting spanked during a visit by her grown daughter and son in law. then it occurred to me that it might be easier to just use Tina's folks......plus it might add to the story since Tina and Steve are already known to my viewers . my theory is that a naughty girl is never too old to get a well deserved spanking and i'm betting many CSR viewers would subscribe to that theory . i am planning on having some fun with this toon and i'll do my best to see that you do enjoy it . thanks, phil

hi everyone,

it appears that Vicky is having a very strong reaction to the idea that Ulysses is going to spank her ......and Tina is having a very strong reaction to Vicky's reaction ..............LOL. however, as Steve noted, we're stepping right along now . i hope you enjoy the new pic. phil

Things are progressing nicely, i see! And it looks like one of the "family traditions" in your story is that when Ulysses orders one of his girls to come to him, she'd better not hesitate! Vicky is just adding up the spankable offences, isn't she?

The two witnesses are having different reactions. Tina appears to be a bit embarrassed for her mother, and, of course is reminded of times when she was the one getting spanked. Steve, on the other hand looks like he's enjoying the show! I myself do not know what it's like to have a youthful-looking pretty mother-in-law, but I'm thinking that ... in this instance... he might even be somewhat excited at the thought that Vicky is likely to have her skirt raised... ...and maybe, she'll even get her panties pulled down! And maybe, he's going to learn something by watching an older, more experienced spanker handling his wife's bad behavior!

Love some fight from Vicky before her spanking also like how Tina`s husband is watching and enjoy maybe he learning from his Father n Law on how to deal with a headstrong wife Can`t wait to see Vicky get it bare bottom in front of them

hugob00m wrote:Things are progressing nicely, i see! And it looks like one of the "family traditions" in your story is that when Ulysses orders one of his girls to come to him, she'd better not hesitate! Vicky is just adding up the spankable offences, isn't she?

hi Boom,

it seems Vicky is indeed adding up spankable offenses.........both from what Ulysses has told her and also from Tina's thoughts about consequences . Vicky has to know this but i guess some girls are just stubborn .

hugob00m wrote:The two witnesses are having different reactions. Tina appears to be a bit embarrassed for her mother, and, of course is reminded of times when she was the one getting spanked. Steve, on the other hand looks like he's enjoying the show! I myself do not know what it's like to have a youthful-looking pretty mother-in-law, but I'm thinking that ... in this instance... he might even be somewhat excited at the thought that Vicky is likely to have her skirt raised... ...and maybe, she'll even get her panties pulled down! And maybe, he's going to learn something by watching an older, more experienced spanker handling his wife's bad behavior!

Tina and Steve are having different reactions to the threatened spanking and that seemed reasonable to me . we'll see more of Steve's thoughts next week...........and the week after and the week after etc. . i also agree with you that he's gonna learn some things from watching Ulysses dealing with his naughty bride . as far as Vicky's skirt being raised............i know i would be wanting to see that and see what she looks like under there . more next week. thanks, phil

butch46163@yahoo.com wrote:Love some fight from Vicky before her spanking also like how Tina`s husband is watching and enjoy maybe he learning from his Father n Law on how to deal with a headstrong wife Can`t wait to see Vicky get it bare bottom in front of them

hi Butch,

well, Vicky does seem to be giving some resistance to getting a public spanking . as i told Boom, like Steve, i know i would be watching and enjoying all this and hoping to see more of Vicky as the spanking unfolds and it seems you agree too . i'm glad you're enjoying the story so far . more coming next week. thanks, phil

Well, we are indeed stepping along quite nicely ! What I like best about this panel is the contrast between Tina's reaction and Steve's: Tina is apparently experiencing Vicky's predicament vicariously while Steve is settling back to enjoy the show (I know just how he feels ).

As we all know, one way of increasing the spankee's embarrassment during a spanking is to have witnesses present, and as we have discussed somewhere here in Phil's forum it's not that uncommon a fantasy among spanko women. To actually get a "public" spanking is a pretty terrifying thought though, so in practice I have only seen this happen with particularly bratty or exhibitionistic female spankos.

Anyway, not to put too fine a point on it, I can't wait to see Vicky get what's coming to her !

web-ed wrote:Well, we are indeed stepping along quite nicely ! What I like best about this panel is the contrast between Tina's reaction and Steve's: Tina is apparently experiencing Vicky's predicament vicariously while Steve is settling back to enjoy the show (I know just how he feels ).

hi web-ed,

as i said to Boom, the fact that Steve and Tina are having different reactions, seemed entirely reasonable to me . of course, in the case of Steve, i just had him thinking what i would have......stepping along nicely .

web-ed wrote:As we all know, one way of increasing the spankee's embarrassment during a spanking is to have witnesses present, and as we have discussed somewhere here in Phil's forum it's not that uncommon a fantasy among spanko women. To actually get a "public" spanking is a pretty terrifying thought though, so in practice I have only seen this happen with particularly bratty or exhibitionistic female spankos.

you're luckier than i am. i have never seen it happen...........although i would certainly love to .

web-ed wrote: Anyway, not to put to fine a point on it, I can't wait to see Vicky get what's coming to her !

Steve and Tina may be having different reactions to Vicky's threatened spanking but i have a hunch that they each share your viewpoint thanks, phil

hi everyone,

do to circumstances beyond my control, i am posting tomorrow's pic today . Tina is still thinking about the times she got spanked by her dad . Steve and Vicky are still more interested in what's happening to Vicky right now..............although for different reasons . i hope you enjoy the new pic . phil

We've got some great anticipation here as Vicky is unceremoniously thrown over Ulysses' knee - Tina can't help but be empathetic because she naturally places herself in her mother's position having been there so often herself, while Steve, who looks at the situation just like the typical CSR reader would , eagerly awaits what comes next. And in this case, what comes next is Vicky's bare bottom, and getting her panties taken down in front of Steve should completely mortify her.

It's not every couple who has a view of a big fountain out their dining room window, but I guess Ulysses and Vicky do . And when you see that Overbarrel decoration on the dining room table you have to think that an award from House Beautiful cannot be far behind ( ) . Or at least an award from CSR .

web-ed wrote:We've got some great anticipation here as Vicky is unceremoniously thrown over Ulysses' knee - Tina can't help but be empathetic because she naturally places herself in her mother's position having been there so often herself, while Steve, who looks at the situation just like the typical CSR reader would , eagerly awaits what comes next. And in this case, what comes next is Vicky's bare bottom, and getting her panties taken down in front of Steve should completely mortify her.

hi web-ed,

yeah, Tina is indeed being empathetic because of her own experiences over her Dad's lap. of course, as she remembers some of those spankings and her Mom's role in them, her attitude might be shifting a little bit . and yeah, Steve is just like we are .

web-ed wrote:It's not every couple who has a view of a big fountain out their dining room window, but I guess Ulysses and Vicky do . And when you see that Overbarrel decoration on the dining room table you have to think that an award from House Beautiful cannot be far behind ( ) . Or at least an award from CSR

i'll settle for happy viewers . as for the fountain. it was part of the scene. i could have changed it but i guess it wasn't bothering me . thanks, phil

overbarrel49 wrote:Tina is still thinking about the times she got spanked by her dad.

I can see that Tina started out identifying with her mother... at first! But, as she remembers her childhood spankings in more detail, it turns out that it was her mother who insisted that she suffer the humiliation of having witnesses. Maybe... as things progress, she'll begin to appreciate the justice of the current situation. Now her mother is being humiliated and SHE is the witness! (one of them!)

overbarrel49 wrote:Steve and Vicky are still more interested in what's happening to Vicky right now..............although for different reasons.

As web-ed already commented and you confirmed, Steve is kicking back and enjoying the show! (Just like we would in his place!) He can see that Vicky, in spite of being old enough to have a grown and married daughter, is still quite attractive, and she looks really sexy turned over her husband's knee with her skirt raised! But there's more! It looks like Ulysses is about to pull Vicky's panties down... giving Steve even more to look at!

And Vicky... well it appears she's gotten herself into the predicament she's in, and now, she's going to have to suffer the humiliation of a bare-bottomed spanking in front of witnesses! But she used to think that was alright for her daughter, didn't she?

hugob00m wrote:I can see that Tina started out identifying with her mother... at first! But, as she remembers her childhood spankings in more detail, it turns out that it was her mother who insisted that she suffer the humiliation of having witnesses. Maybe... as things progress, she'll begin to appreciate the justice of the current situation. Now her mother is being humiliated and SHE is the witness! (one of them!)

hi Boom,

i think you are right on the money here . Tina is indeed remembering her spankings at home in greater detail and seems to be wondering why she was feeling sorry for her Mom ............and she does seem to be leaning more towards enjoying her Mom's current situation .

hugob00m wrote:As web-ed already commented and you confirmed, Steve is kicking back and enjoying the show! (Just like we would in his place!) He can see that Vicky, in spite of being old enough to have a grown and married daughter, is still quite attractive, and she looks really sexy turned over her husband's knee with her skirt raised! But there's more! It looks like Ulysses is about to pull Vicky's panties down... giving Steve even more to look at!

And Vicky... well it appears she's gotten herself into the predicament she's in, and now, she's going to have to suffer the humiliation of a bare-bottomed spanking in front of witnesses! But she used to think that was alright for her daughter, didn't she?

Steve is indeed kicking back, ready to enjoy the show........just as we would . However, Ulysses has not yet pulled up Vicky's dress. he has just now turned her OTK and is just talking about what he's going to do next . Vicky certainly is in a predicament for sure .............and, as you mentioned, she did think such predicaments were OK for her daughters. those past episodes may come back to haunt her as you have surmised but i am unwilling to say just how at this time . i'm glad you're enjoying the toon so far. thanks, phil

Ulysses S Grant is spanking Vicky. Can we expect any other dead Presidents to show up?

willjohn wrote:Ulysses S Grant is spanking Vicky. Can we expect any other dead Presidents to show up?

hi Willjohn,

since i needed a name that started with U and Ulysses was the only good one i could think of, i decided what the hell . i do not have any plans to have other dead presidents showing up in this toon thanks, phil

Hi Phil, I could not help but imagine a flashback spanking that Tina got from her dad while her mother watched (she would have been a teenager of spanking age of course) and think how great it was that the roles were now reversed. Thanks for a great series. Have a great day.
Jim

jimc wrote:Hi Phil, I could not help but imagine a flashback spanking that Tina got from her dad while her mother watched (she would have been a teenager of spanking age of course) and think how great it was that the roles were now reversed. Thanks for a great series. Have a great day.
Jim

hi Jim,

i couldn't help but imagine it either..............which is how this story got started in the first place . i thought the idea of the Mom getting spanked instead of the daughter was an appealing one and besides, i've always thought that naughty girls are never too old to get spanked . i'm glad you're enjoying the story so far . more to come. thanks, phil

Looking in my crystal ball I see mother & daughter having bottoms spanked.
Looking again into my crystal ball I see 2 pairs of panties being removed.
looking further into my crystal ball I see 2 bare bottoms being spanked
Looking even further into my crystal ball i see implements being employed on bare bottoms.
With or without the crystal ball I see 2 attractive women eating off the mantel piece & sleeping on their stomachs.
Willjohn the amazing has spoken.

willjohn wrote:Looking in my crystal ball I see mother & daughter having bottoms spanked.
Looking again into my crystal ball I see 2 pairs of panties being removed.
looking further into my crystal ball I see 2 bare bottoms being spanked
Looking even further into my crystal ball i see implements being employed on bare bottoms.
With or without the crystal ball I see 2 attractive women eating off the mantel piece & sleeping on their stomachs.
Willjohn the amazing has spoken.

hi Willjohn.

interesting predictions . i can't tell if Willjohn the amazing is just naturally suspicious or if he's just seen a lot of my toons:lol: . either way, these predictions do seem reasonable. we'll keep the predictions of Willjohn the amazing on file here so we can refer to them as the toon goes on . thanks, phil

hi everyone,

things are picking up now and there are all kinds of interesting things going on ...........with varying reactions i. if i had to pick just one though, i think i'd have to say Steve is having the most fun at this point . i hope you enjoy the new pic . phil