nice rosy cheeks by Doc Cylon this week as usual. the second scan of the Kirk Stiles secretary spanked by female boss is vastly superior as you mentioned. i like the bending over position and the idea that she won't be doing any sitting around
![Laughing :lol:](./images/smilies/icon_lol.gif)
![Laughing :lol:](./images/smilies/icon_lol.gif)
![Very Happy :D](./images/smilies/icon_e_biggrin.gif)
![Very Happy :D](./images/smilies/icon_e_biggrin.gif)
Oh yes! This is my favorite part of your update this week!web-ed wrote:Robin spanks Batgirl by David Marshall. An extended spanking scene in which Robin has finally had enough!
Indeed! Let's savor those pages! Sometime I'd like to know the rest of the story of "Batgirl's Bad Day" and maybe if there was any specific reason for Robin to decide that Batgirl needed to be spanked right then and there. Was there a "last straw", that pushed Robin past the limits of his patience? Was it just the cumulative effect of dealing with her usual haughtiness? Or, maybe, considering her remark about his hard-on poking her belly... it was just that he was so sexually frustrated by her flirtiness, and her provocative costume, that he had to do something!web-ed wrote:Let's savor two pages of "Batgirl's Bad Day", taking up the story where Robin has had enough and decides it's time to take her OTK. Marshall appears to have done this using traditional comic-art techniques - ink on paper (we don't know if he pencilled it first, but he probably did). Note the cameo appearance of Jughead Jones from Archie in the first panel.
Didn't it seem like every character that Yvonne Craig ever played should've been spanked?web-ed wrote:Batgirl was always somewhat impudent in the comics, and as played by Yvonne Craig on TV we really wanted to see her get taken down a peg because of the "haughty, I-deserve-to-be-spanked attitude"
You're most welcome, Dan! Nothing I like better than sharing my spanking discoveries (and essays) with my friends.daneldorado wrote:Oh Dear God, this week's new updates contain two of the most orgasmically delightful spanking images ever to come down the pike. Thank you so much!
As far as I know, Marshall never finished the story. It's possible he might still do so - as you know, the artist's life isn't an easy one, and sometimes favorite projects have to sit on the back burner while the rent is being paid with other things. One of the great things about it is that it is a whole story, which allowed for an extended spanking scene over a number of separate panels.hugob00m wrote:Sometime I'd like to know the rest of the story of "Batgirl's Bad Day" and maybe if there was any specific reason for Robin to decide that Batgirl needed to be spanked right then and there.
So you want to know more about the relative ages of the Dynamic Duo (plus 1), but couldn't find this information elsewhere? Because all these characters have been "retconned" it's confusing trying to tell one version from another in sources like Wikipedia (which I wouldn't rely on for anything important anyway). Curious to know if Robin might be spanking an older woman, much like Tommy and Miss Johnson? Well, you've come to the right placedaneldorado wrote: I have tried to do research on the Batman-Robin-Batgirl characters, but nothing on Google or Wikipedia tells me their respective ages. Of course Batman is the oldest of the three, his story having debuted in 1939, and Robin the Boy Wonder came along (as a teenager) in 1940. But we never know their respective ages. Batgirl apparently did not arrive on the scene until 1967; but in comic book depictions as well as on TV and movie screens, she seems to be about Robin's age.
There was no romance between Batman and Batgirl #2 (Barbara Gordon) in the 60's comics, although of course there could have been a gimmicky cover with Batgirl wearing a bridal veil or something. I almost seem to remember such a scene, but I think I'm just mixing it up with Supergirl marrying Mr. Mxyzptlk, which really was on a cover. However, I checked the relevant cover scans of Batman and Detective from 1967 - 1970 just now and couldn't find anything. Batman did romance Batwoman (Kathy Kane) in the early 60's, but I can't recall offhand how close to marriage they ever came. Very likely Kathy was ready to marry but Bruce wasn't.butch46163@yahoo.com wrote:HI WEB-ED CSR!! Wasn`t there a comic back in the 60 where Batman was going to marry Batgirl? Meaning she has to be older than robin!Can`t say much about the new Batgirl who was a young girl that came after Robin left to become Nightwings! If anyone who I thought would give Batgirl a spanking it has to be the Joker!
I have one more piece from Tim, a rather odd Superman/Lois spanking with belt and rhyming dialogue, which I may try to squeeze in this summer if I start doing one spanking from the "Superman Family" each week once all the "Batman Family" stuff is used up. Otherwise, we'll see it some time later.tanner wrote:And lets have more of Tim's work.
You're very welcome, Phil. My comments about few lines may have been an over-simplification and are certainly debatable, but I do feel I'm on to something. I think the only work of Funbun I've ever posted on CSR has been some of his bare-bottom modifications, and it's possible that many CSR readers are unfamiliar with his work. I certainly regret the difficulty I had in saving the attachments on the Artastic Forum, because I didn't have time to get to Funbun's art, and while AF was still up I didn't want to repost Funbun's original work since AF was basically his baby. I just did a quick search of my old files, and I came up with this example: This is certainly a fairly erotic piece given its handicap of being F/F, and it's undeniable that Funbun made do with relatively few lines. Without trying to sound like I'm walking away from my original point, I think that although few lines are used, the style is much different than caricature/shorthand, and that more details (as we would get from, say, Serpieri) would probably make it even more erotic. It's a subject worthy of more debate, and once I've got some time freed up (ha!) I plan to do a short article on Eroticism in Comic Art, in which we can explore these ideas further.overbarrel49 wrote:when i was reading about using few lines i got to thinking about Funbun. now i don't draw so i might be wrong about this but Funbun also seems to use this "shorthand" method of drawing but i think some of his stuff is pretty erotic. for one thing, there are the nice full bottoms as well as the camera angles. in addition to these i think Funbun shows more action than did DeCarlo. i would be interested in hearing what the rest of you have to say about this. in any case, i loved the article and i appreciate the time you spent getting this ready to present to us.
You're very welcome, Dan, and I appreciate your kind words.daneldorado wrote: The toon you call "Secretary Spanking No. 28" by Kirk Stiles is very interesting in spite of the fact that no spanking can be seen. The look of this toon cries out, "Spanking Coming Up!" and demands our attention. You have invited us to "take a look and decide for yourselves" whether the secretary is crying before her spanking or is crying for more afterward. The beauty of it is that, whichever option we choose, EITHER ONE is correct!
I agree that the secretary here is beautifully drawn, but I wonder if her left hand is really "rubbing her sore bottom." To me, that hand is positioned much HIGHER than where the meat of her buttocks would be. Since -- as you point out -- the boss is clearly beckoning her to get over his lap for a spanking, I get the feeling that her hand is just resting on her hip, as in "Oh dear, now I'm really in for it!" And that would mean, she has not actually been spanked... yet. But as I said above, either interpretation would be correct in our vivid imaginations.
Your essay on the "Comparison of the Humorama Big Five Plus One Spanking Cartoonists" merits much praise, as it reflects the enormous amount of work you have put into it.
Of your “Five plus one” I would submit that Bill Ward is the best pure artist of the lot, but his sense of humor is sadly beneath the other four. You put it well:
“I suspect the anger shown by many of his male spankers is a reflection of a hostility towards women.” Of course I don’t know the reasons behind your summation, but you’re right: None of Ward’s M/F spanking toons show any sympathy for the women. Stiles does, and so do Wenzel and DeCarlo. Perhaps Homer Provence was the most female-friendly spank artist, for he frequently has the spankee female deliver the punch line. “I know Morse code, Dear, and I love you too.”
Speaking of Provence, in presenting this essay you accidentally displayed an example of my Number One Fetish. No, it isn’t Spanking, though of course female spanking is very high on my fet-list. But my Number One, all-time, HIGHEST fetish is seeing a pretty woman raise her skirt to show her legs. And waddaya know, in your essay about the Big Five Plus One, you show us a Homer Provence cartoon where a girl is doing exactly that. Magnifique!
Your friend “Tim” has given us another of his pencil sketches, this time with Batman spanking Catwoman. While his drawings do nothing for me, this post is interesting because you bring up the phrase “Papa spank!” And you’re right, back in the 1940s that phrase was used often. In the famous film “Casablanca” (1942) Humphrey Bogart suggests to Claude Rains that he does the Gestapo’s bidding because otherwise, “Gestapo Spank!”
But the phrase was already popular by then. I’ve seen and heard mention of it several times, not only in the 1948 musical “Kiss Me Kate,” but elsewhere.
Thanks again for the updates, Web-ed. You always come through for us.
hi web-ed,web-ed wrote:This is certainly a fairly erotic piece given its handicap of being F/F, and it's undeniable that Funbun made do with relatively few lines. Without trying to sound like I'm walking away from my original point, I think that although few lines are used, the style is much different than caricature/shorthand, and that more details (as we would get from, say, Serpieri) would probably make it even more erotic. It's a subject worthy of more debate, and once I've got some time freed up (ha!) I plan to do a short article on Eroticism in Comic Art, in which we can explore these ideas further.