Chicago Spanking Review

Dixie Dugan Spanking #2

Comics Gallery 2


We have mixed feelings about off-stage spankings. Technically, we refuse to count them as real spankings, and don't put them into the Comics Spanking Data Base. We also always feel somewhat cheated, for although there can be legitimate dramatic reasons for showing us the reactions of people outside the room where the spanking is taking place, there isn't any good reason not to show the spanking itself. Take an extra panel or two, for goodness sake, and show us the spanking! (The same applies to off-camera movie spankings).

This is a father/daughter scene of the type we've encountered before, where the father realizes he should have administered the spanking years ago but goes ahead now that his daughter is grown on the "better late than never" principle. Although we can say it isn't Dixie we see here, we don't know who the characters are, nor can we say what year this was originally published. The father does at least seem serious about applying some real discipline, for he produces a hairbrush - visible if you look carefully at this photostatic reproduction.

dixie dugan father daughter spanking

© McNaught Syndicate Inc. Year of publication unknown. Posted by the Web-Ed on 04/01/2011.


05/17/2019 Update: After eight years, it looks like this is another mystery solved by CSR Chief Strip Researcher Sweetspot, who has definitely established the dates this episode was published as September 11-15, 1948. The spankee is a girl named Brenda, who has poisoned the mind of Dixie's beau by telling him that Dixie is chasing after Brenda's husband Phil (interesting coincidence in the name). Brenda's father realizes that it's hairbrush time!laughing face

Let's see Phil's (our Phil's ubergeek) scans of the episode now.

dixie dugan sept 11, 1948

Dixie Dugan September 11, 1948.

dixie dugan sept 13, 1948

Dixie Dugan September 13, 1948.

dixie dugan sept 14, 1948 spanking scene

Dixie Dugan September 14, 1948. (We believe this one came from the St. Louis Post-Dispatch).

dixie dugan sept 15, 1948 after the spanking

Dixie Dugan September 15, 1948. © McNaught Syndicate Inc.

dixie dugan sept 15, 1948

After the spanking, Brenda says she's embarrassed, trying to pretend the spanking didn't hurt, but she's rubbing her bottom - a very good sign! Scans by Sweetspot slightly enhanced by Web-Ed. © McNaught Syndicate Inc. Posted by the Web-Ed on 05/17/2019.


next page button NEXT ENTRY - Jane Gets Spanked
previous page button PREVIOUS ENTRY - Dixie Dugan #1
return to comics page button COMICS PAGE 2 - Return to Comics Page 2
return to home page button HOME - Return to Home Page