Chicago Spanking Review

Tillie the Toiler Meets Mac the Spanker

---> Comics Gallery 2


tillie the toiler gets spanked

Date of publication unknown. © King Features Syndicate. Posted by the Web-Ed on 03/11/2011.

The 1920's was a decade of rapid change and progress in American society. Increasing industrialization led to greater prosperity and opportunity for many, including women. While men were still expected to be the primary breadwinners, unmarried women could and did establish independent careers, and this was reflected in comic strips like Winnie Winkle (which we'll examine next week) and Tillie the Toiler, which we see here.

We don't know exactly when this first appeared, but we think the spanker is Tillie's co-worker and admirer Clarence "Mac" McDougall. Why is he spanking her? We can only guess it has something to do with Tillie's tendency to date numerous men, another by-product of women's increasing freedom, which when taken to extremes led to the wild "flapper" who certainly needed to be brought under control by spanking (see also Red Hot Spanking Stories for more on flapper-spanking). If so, this spanking is fully justified since Mac is quite devoted to Tillie (they finally married in the very last Sunday installment of the strip in 1959).

One other note: Stan Lee must have had Tillie in the back of his mind in the 1940's when he named such Marvel titles as Millie the Model and Nellie the Nurse.

tillie the toiler gets spanked

Found at Veralsi.

This looks like another panel from what must have been an entire spanking sequence, unless it was the only one originally and someone later created the one above from it.


10/05/2018 update: CSR Chief Strip Researcher Sweetspot decided to look into the question of the original publication date and determined it to be April 2, 1938. This was a Saturday, but it was probably intended for Sunday publication since there are four three-panel tiers and the date "4-3" appears in the last of these. (It was not unknown for newspapers to jump the gun and print a Sunday comic on Saturday, although that meant juggling things around somewhat or perhaps not printing the Saturday episode of that particular strip). Let's take a look at the whole thing now:

tillie the toiler gets spanked in the april 2, 1938 strip
tillie the toiler gets spanked in the april 2, 1938 strip
tillie the toiler gets spanked in the april 2, 1938 strip
tillie the toiler gets spanked in the april 2, 1938 strip

Tillie the Toiler, April 2, 1938. Scan by Sweetspot. © King Features Syndicate.

tillie the toiler gets spanked in the april 2, 1938 strip

The second of two spanking panels. Scan by Sweetspot. © King Features Syndicate. Posted by the Web-Ed on 10/05/2018.

We now have answers to our questions about this spanking: it was certainly justified, as even Tillie's own mother realized, by going out with some guy named Dick on the eve of his wedding and breaking it up (this was typical behavior for Tillie), and we know when it first appeared. While 1938 was technically after the "Flapper" era, Tillie was acting just like one - wild and loose - and needed the "flapper treatment," i.e. spanking.

What about the art? Russ Westover was a competent if unspectacular artist who employed a number of assistants during the strip's run. Two things stand out: Tillie was very pretty and she was always dressed in the latest fashions, as would be expected for someone employed in the clothing industry. Her outfit here reminds us of the one worn by the spankee in the Ladies Home Journal. spanking from ladies home journal


next page button NEXT ENTRY - Winnie Winkle
previous page button PREVIOUS ENTRY - Texas Slim
return to comics page button COMICS PAGE 2 - Return to Comics Page 2
return to home page button HOME - Return to Home Page